I just happened to notice some extremely negative remarks on Wikipedia
about Eric Schiller posted by somebody who obviously does not like
him. Naturally, I suspected Taylor Kingston aka Edward Winter, who is
known to attack Schiller among others.
So, I revised the Eric Schiller page, taking out all the negative
stuff. Within minutes, this same person but them all back in. Then,
checking the history, I could see that this has happened several times
before.
Accordingly, I have requested that this negative poster be banned from
Wikipedia. Any other suggestions?
Here is what I wrote, just now, at
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Eric_Schiller
Talk:Eric Schiller
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
I strongly object to the negative remarks made by Camembert on the
Eric Schiller biography. In the first place, Camembert is not a chess
player, or at least this name is unknown to chess. In addition, it can
seen by his remarks about Judit Polgar that he knows nothing about
chess or about her. It is further objectional that somebody can use a
fake name to attack somebody on Wikipedia.
What I am objecting to is the following remarks by Camembert, "Many of
them have received scathing reviews: reviewing for the Chess Cafe,
Carsten Hansen said Schiller's tome on the Frankenstein-Dracula
Variation of the Vienna Game was "by far THE WORST BOOK I HAVE EVER
SEEN" [1], while Tony Miles' famous review of Unorthodox Chess
Openings for Kingpin consisted of two words: "Utter crap."
I revised Schiller's biography and within just a few minutes Camembert
put this all back in. I feel that he should be banned and blacklisted
from Wikipedia for this.
The fact is that Eric Schiller has written more than one hundred
published books on chess and dozens of published articles in academic
publications on Linguistics. If he were such a bad writer as Camembert
claims, nobody would buy his books and no publisher would publish
them. In addition, the authors of the two negative reviews which
Camembert cites were political oponents of Schiller (one of whom is
now dead), so it is simply wrong to cite them.
I request that Camembert who knows nothing of which he speaks be
banned from Wikipedia.