wrote:
1. Did Susan Polgar make Statement A, dated July 27, 2006, and quoted
in full [upthread]?

2. Did Sam Sloan make Statement B below in USCF BINFO 200603590, dated
September 26, 2006, and quoted in full (with email address redactions)
[upthread]?

3. Did Sloan make Statement C [upthread] on January 5, 2007, as his full
response to Count 13 of a USCF ethics complaint?

4. Do you find these three statements equally credible? Discuss.

5. Assume, in arguendo, that Polgar's Statement A is substantially true
and that Sloan's Statement B and Statement C were substantially untrue.
What conclusions would you reach about Sloan's character? About
Polgar's character?

6. Assume, in arguendo, that Polgar's Statement A is substantially
untrue and that Sloan's Statement B and Statement C were substantially
true. What conclusions would you reach about Sloan's character? About
Polgar's character?

7. Assume, in arguendo, that Polgar's Statement A, Sloan's Statement B,
and Sloan's Statement C are all substantially untrue. What conclusions
would you reach about Sloan's character? About Polgar's character?